The Hermeneutical Aspects of Proving the Pope’s Primacy in the Work of Ivan Dubovich „Hierarchia abo o zwierzchności w Cerkwi Bożej” (1644)
 
 
Więcej
Ukryj
1
Shevchenko Institute of Literature of the National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine (Ukraine, Kyiv)
Data publikacji: 01-03-2018
Data nadesłania: 22-12-2017
Data ostatniej rewizji: 22-01-2018
Data akceptacji: 12-02-2018
 
Intercultural Communication 2018;4(1):159–174
SŁOWA KLUCZOWE
DZIEDZINY
STRESZCZENIE ARTYKUŁU
Purpose:
To research fundamentals of bishop of Rome primacy justified by Ivan Dubovich in his work „Hierarchia abo o zwierzchności w Cerkwi Bożej” (1644). To reveal methods of interpretation of the Holy Bible fragments in the patristic works, to analyze used rhetorical modes.

Material and methods:
Historical, cultural and hermeneutic methods have been used.

Conclusions:
The main question in the book of Ivan Dubovich „Hierarchia abo o zwierzchności w Cerkwi Bożej” (1644) is the foundation of primacy of the Pope. The polemicist proved the authority of the Bishop of Rome based on the texts of Holy Bible, works of the Greek Church Doctors in „O zwierzchnosci Piotra s”chapter. While considering this problem the author referred to the Gospels fragments, which Roman Catholic theological writers interpreted as an argument of Apostle Peter primacy, as well as to prays and hymns of the church. Ivan Dubovich revealed himself as a Scripturist, connoisseur of ancient Greek philosophy. In the the research the conception of the church’s organization stated by Ivan Dubovich has been reviewed in context of orthodox theologians’ ideas, historical and cultural background of that time. Besides, different rhetorical, literary modes used by the author in order to prove the catholic doctrine of papal primacy have been revealed in the report.

 
REFERENCJE (22)
1.
Averentsev, S. (2007). Dvanadtsiat apostoliv. Sofiya-Logos. Slovnyk. [The twelve apostles. Sofia-Logos. Dictionary]. Kyiv: Duh i Litera. (In Ukrainian).
 
2.
AXIOS: tayinstvo ludskoyi pryrody. [Axios: the mystery of human nature]. (2015). Kyiv: Vydavnychyy viddil UPC Kyivskogo Patriarhatu. (In Ukrainian).
 
3.
Bibliya. Knyhy sviashchenogo pysannia starogo ta novogo zavitu. [The Holy Bible. The books of sacred Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments]. (2004). Kyiv: Vydannia Kyyivskoyi Patriarhiyi Ukrayinskoyi Pravoslavnoyi Tserkvy Kyyivskogo Patriarhatu. (In Ukrainian).
 
4.
Bulgakov, S. (1991). Tserkovnaya iyerarhiya. [The hierarchy of the Church]. Katehizys. [The Catechism]. Kyiv: Izdaniye Ukrainskoy Pravoslavnoy Tserkvi. pp. 240-252. (In Russian).
 
5.
Chodynicki, K. (1939-1946). Dubowicz Jan. Polski słownik biograficzny. Kraków: Polska Akademia Umiejętności. T. V. S. 436 ‒ 437.
 
6.
Dubowicz, Ioann. (1644). Hierarchia abo o zwierzchosci w cerkwi Bozey. Lwow. (In Ukrainian).
 
7.
Evseviy Kesariyskiy. (2013). Tserkovnaya istoriya. [The history of the Church]. Saint Petersburg. (In Russian).
 
8.
Gerder, Iogann. (1977). Ideyi k filosofiyi istoriyi chelovechestva. [The ideas to philosophy of the human history]. Moscow: Nauka. (In Russian).
 
9.
Holovata, N. (2003). Balaban Hedeon. [Balaban Gideon]. Entsyklopediya istoriyi Ukrayiny: v 5 t. [The encyclopedia of history of Ukraine: in 5 volumes]. Kyiv. T. 1 (A-B). (In Ukrainian).
 
10.
Knyha pravyl sviatyh apostoliv, vselenskyh i pomisnyh soboriv, i sviatyh ottsiv. [The book of the rules of saint apostles, oecumenical and local councils, and saint fathers]. (2008). Tr. Chokaliuk, S.M. Kyiv: Presa Ukrayiny. (In Ukrainian).
 
11.
Kreuza, Leon. (1617). Obrona iednosci cerkiewney abo Dowody, ktorymi się pokazuie, iż grecka cerkiew z łacinską ma być ziednoczona. Wilno.
 
12.
Novakovskyy, P. (2005). Liturhiyna problematyka v mizhkonfesiyniy polemitsi pislia Beresteyskoi unii (1596‒1720). [Liturgical issues in interconfessional polemic after the Union of Brest (1596-1720)]. Lviv. (In Ukrainian).
 
13.
Shaff, F. (2011). Istoriya hristianskoy tserkvi. Nikeyskoye i poslenikeyskoye hristianstvo. Ot Konstantina Velykogo do Hryhoriya Velykogo (311 ‒ 590 g. po R.H.). [History of the Christian Church. Nicene and Post-Nicene Christianity. From Constantine the Great to Gregory the Great. a d. 311 ‒ 590]. T.III. Saint Petersburg. (In Russian).
 
14.
Shevchenko, V.M. (2004). Slovnyk-dovidnyk z relihiyeznavstva. [The dictionary-reference book]. Kyiv: Naukova dumka. (In Ukrainian).
 
15.
Tkachuk, Ruslan. (2013). Litopys podiy. [The chronicle of events]. Istoriya ukrayinskoyi literatury u 12 tt. [The history of Ukrainian literature in 12 volumes]. Kyiv: Naukova dumka. T. 1.: Davnia literatura (X ‒ persha polovyna XVI st.). pp. 804-810. (In Ukrainian).
 
16.
Tkachuk, Ruslan. (2017). Ekleziolohichna dumka Ivana Dubovycha u knyzi „Hierarchia abo o zwierzchności w Cerkwi Bożej”. [Ecclesiological thought of Ivan Dubovich in the work „Hierarchia abo o zwierzchności w Cerkwi Bożej”]. Mova i kultura. [Language and culture]. Kyiv: Vydavnychyy dim Dmytra Buraho. T. 189. Pp. 181-190. (In Ukrainian).
 
17.
Vasiliy Vielikiy, arhiyepiskop Kesariyi Kappadokiyskoy. (2009). Tvoreniya. [The works]. Moskva. T. I. (In Russian).
 
18.
Vasyliy Velykyy. (1989). Monashi nayky dlia tyh, shcho podvyzayutsia v monastyri i na samoti. Asketychni tvory sv. ottsia nashogo Vasylia Velykogo. [The claustral rules for those, who live in monastery and in solitude. The ascetic works of saint our father Basil the Great]. Rym. (In Ukrainian).
 
19.
Wagilewicz, J.D. (1996). Pisarze polscy rusini. Przemyśł: Południowo-wschodni instytut naukowy w Przemyślu.
 
20.
Zlatoust, Ioann. (1896). Tvoreniya sviatago ottsa nashogo Ioanna Zlatousta, arhiyepiskopa Konstantinopolskago, v russkom perevode. [The works of saint our father John Chrysostom, archbishop of Constantinople, in Russian translation]. T. IX. Kn. I. Saint Petersburg. (In Russian).
 
21.
Zlatoust, Ioann. (1896). Tvoreniya sviatago ottsa nashogo Ioanna Zlatousta, arhiyepiskopa Konstantinopolskago, v russkom perevode. [The works of saint our father John Chrysostom, archbishop of Constantinople, in Russian translation]. T. II. Kn. I. Saint Petersburg. (In Russian).
 
22.
Zlatoust, Ioann. (1902). Tvoreniya sviatago ottsa nashogo Ioanna Zlatousta, arhiyepiskopa Konstantinopolskago, v russkom perevode. [The works of saint our father John Chrysostom, archbishop of Constantinople, in Russian translation]. T. VIII. Kn. I. Saint Petersburg. (In Russian).
 
eISSN:2543-7461
ISSN:2451-0998